🤖 Your Next Competitor Is AI — the Buyer/Seller Whisperer Playbook

SCALE WITH LIBERTAS & EXP REALTY

🎧 Listen on Apple Podcasts and Spotify!

Your clients are using AI. They're asking it what a house is worth, what they should offer, whether the inspection is scary, how much repairs should cost, whether they should wait for rates to fall — and sometimes whether the advice their agent is giving them is any good.

So no, this isn't another podcast about how to use ChatGPT to write a listing description. We're past that. The bigger question is: what happens when your client has ChatGPT sitting on their side of the negotiating table? Today we work through it — from AI as competitor, to AI as your ally, to the specific human skills that AI genuinely cannot replicate.

Topic first came up on our sister podcast Powerhouse Talk — an assembly show with Chris Heller (former Keller Williams CEO), Kacie Anderson (a young Florida agent already producing $50-60M annually), Dan Lesniak (runs one of the largest teams in the country), and Orlando Montiel. Bigger-picture conversations about where the market is going. If this podcast is where the market is, Powerhouse Talk is where the market's headed. Worth adding to the rotation.

Now let's get into today.

According to research cited by NAR, more than 60% of buyer-side real estate searches now begin through AI interfaces. Whatever the exact percentage is in your specific market, the behavior is already here.

Here's a real scenario. Your buyer sees a house listed at $600,000 that's been on the market for 67 days. Before calling you, they can:

Sellers can ask AI whether your recommended list price makes sense, whether your commission is reasonable, and whether their agent's marketing plan is competitive.

Both sides can ask AI about virtually every input in the transaction — and they do.

That's fine. Let them. What you don't want to do is get irritated every time somebody says "ChatGPT told me this" — the same way you learned not to get irritated when they said "Zillow said that." Your answer should be some version of: "Okay — let's take a look at that."

AI may have an answer, but it probably doesn't know:

AI has information. You have the actual transaction. You're the boots on the ground.

Here's the piece most agents haven't fully absorbed yet. Your customer might not tell you they're checking everything you say with AI. You are crazy not to assume they are.

And it's getting more automatic every quarter. AI is starting to check things for people even without them asking. It'll do it on email. Send your seller an offer, and the AI screening their inbox may have reviewed the entire offer, formed a preliminary opinion, and started drafting counter-language — before your seller even opens the message.

Within the next 12-18 months, AI will start listening to conversations and coaching your clients in real time — fact-checking your CMA, questioning your pricing rationale, suggesting counter-strategies mid-conversation. That's where all this is going.

Which means the professional move is to head off the AI response at the pass by using AI yourself — first. Before every listing appointment. Before every offer presentation. Before every difficult conversation with a buyer or seller. Prompt the AI with the full transaction context, get the response you'd want your client to see, and have it in your back pocket.

Here's the specific move that separates professional-grade AI use from amateur-grade. When Julie's on the phone trying to put a complicated deal together — a strange property with no real comps, a lot of moving parts — she doesn't ask about the price first. She asks about motivation.

All of that context matters as much as the price. And when you prompt AI with that level of detail — instead of the amateur-grade "is this a good deal?" — AI gives you a dramatically more useful answer. Sometimes an absolutely killer negotiation strategy you wouldn't have thought of on your own.

The worst thing you can do — regardless of how old you are, regardless of how old your client is — is to try to make AI wrong. You look like a fool. And it might be wrong. But you can't lead with that. Use AI to your advantage. Give it all the facts.

Concrete comparison. Same task — pricing a property.

Bad prompt: "Where should I price this house?"

AI does an okay job pulling from Zillow, Redfin, Realtor.com. Runs a cost-per-square-foot calc. Gives you a reasonable public-data-driven estimate.

Good prompt:

Wildly different quality of output. Same tool. Same underlying data. The difference is you fed it what an experienced professional would consider.

Then take the entire conversation, turn it into a PDF or email, and keep it in your back pocket. If the AI objection comes up from your client, you're already prepared with a professional-grade analysis they can review.

Here's the deeper truth this exposes. If your entire value proposition to clients is information, you're cooked. The information game is lost. Super-intelligence, AGI, ASI, whatever you want to call it — it's going to make high-level information ubiquitous. It'll have virtually no value.

Which means your role has to evolve. You have to become the buyer/seller whisperer.

You're the one who's human. You have intuition. You know their quirks and the features of their personalities. You know that the wife hesitated when the husband said "sure, we can handle that payment." You know the seller's emotional dissonance about leaving a home they've lived in for 30 years. You know the buyer's brother is discouraging the move because of unrelated family drama. You know a hundred small things that AI, no matter how good it gets, cannot see.

That's where the new game is going to be won. Not on the information war. Not on the CMA war. Not on the marketing-material war. On the human-connection war.

People will long forget what you said. They will never forget how you made them feel.

That's always been true. It's just about to become the entire competitive edge for the small group of agents who actually understand it.

Quick tangent on the discoverability side. Traditional SEO isn't dead-dead, but it's on its way out for consumer-facing local search. AI Search is the new game. People aren't Googling "best real estate agent in Nashville" anymore. They're asking ChatGPT or Perplexity or Claude the same question.

Two things we know for sure about how AI systems rank local businesses:

AIs love Reddit. For whatever reason, most major AI systems weight Reddit content unusually heavily. Which means a strategic Reddit presence — a series of high-quality posts focused on your specific micro-market and how to get a house sold in that neighborhood — has an outsized effect on AI search visibility.

Google Business Profile is the second foundational asset. Fully optimized, fully current, with correct descriptions, service areas, categories, and reviews. If yours is neglected, fix it this week.

Here's the specific move for GBP optimization. Open Claude. Give it access to browse the web (through the Chrome extension or whatever the current web-tool integration is — if you don't know what that is, just tell Claude what you want and it'll figure out the tool). Ask Claude:

Claude will audit the profile, produce a fix list, and then actually implement changes with your permission. If it needs a tool it doesn't have, it'll go find or create it. Just tell it what you want in plain English. You don't have to know which extension it needs. That's a skill worth training yourself out of — the "but I don't know the technical details" trap.

Full AEO deep-dive was in a previous newsletter. Worth revisiting if you missed it.

This might be the most important point of the entire episode. The more AI people use, the more valuable actual human contact becomes.

We've all gotten way too comfortable conducting real estate through text messages. Buyer consultations by DM. Listing appointments by email. Everything filtered through a screen. Stop.

Do the buyer consultation in person whenever you can.
Sit at the kitchen table with your sellers.
If you can't meet in person, get on Zoom — and turn your camera on.

Because you learn things when you're sitting across from somebody that no amount of texting will ever produce.

Sometimes the most valuable thing an agent can say is: "You guys got real quiet about that. What's bothering you?" AI will never ask that question. A text thread will never surface it. But a live human sitting across from another human will notice it every single time.

The coaching clients ahead of pace this year are the ones doing one-on-one meetings. In person when possible, Zoom with cameras on when not. Coffee before the appointment. Lunch after the closing. That includes prospects before they even become clients.

Related NAR data point worth revisiting. Over 90% of all real estate business now comes from centers of influence, past clients, repeat business, and referrals. Not paid leads. Not portal purchases. Not TikTok. Not Instagram. From real relationships, human to human.

Which is exactly why almost no one in the industry teaches this — because it can't be monetized. The big real estate conferences and summits over the last 30-60 days? Look at the agendas. None of them are about centers of influence and past clients. Not even a breakout topic. Why? Because the sponsors can't sell you anything around it. There's no whiz-bang lead-gen, branding, or marketing widget attached to just call your database.

Those big events are — bluntly — hackathons to separate you from your credit card. That's harsh but honest.

Here's a new NAR data point worth carrying into every database strategy. Most of the referrals you'll get from your sphere will not come from your closest friends or your brother. They'll come from one or two degrees away from those inner-circle people.

Which means the strategic move is not to obsess over the top 10 people in your sphere. It's to make sure the broader sphere — the 200 people who know you casually, who might mention you at a school event or a golf outing or a dinner party — remains in regular light contact. Those loose-connection people generate most of the referral volume.

Which reinforces why the 5 conversations per day discipline works so well. It's not about the depth of any single conversation. It's about the breadth of contact across a much larger surface area than most agents are willing to maintain.

Julie made a point in coaching last week worth surfacing here. If you have kids in school, five contacts per day is essentially impossible to avoid — if you're actually engaged in normal parent life.

Drop-off. Pickup. Sports practice. School events. PTA. Dance class. Piano lessons. Weekend games. Field trips. Book club. Every one of those environments has other adults who are also parenting. And every one of those interactions can be a real conversation if you decide it will be.

Don't go in with your hoodie and sunglasses trying to sneak out. Have real conversations. You're already out there doing the thing anyway — just be more peopley while you're doing it.

Introverts, we hear you. Julie and Tim are both introverts. Doing this consistently is a skill you build, not a personality trait you're born with.

Take your last 5 closed deals. Honestly answer: what's the actual source of each one?

Four out of five — sometimes five out of five — will trace back to a past client, a repeat client, a referral, or someone within one or two degrees of your sphere. The exception is often someone you met in person at an open house or community event.

None of them will trace back to a TikTok video, an Instagram post, or a paid portal lead. Do the exercise. The math will surprise you.

Quick sub-point that ties the AI thread together. Don't argue with ChatGPT. Pressure-test instead. You've already accepted that AI is here to stay. You're the professional helping your client use it correctly. Sometimes AI will point out something you missed. Sometimes it'll be wrong.

You're trying to get your client to the right decision for them. You're not trying to win a trivia contest against an algorithm. It's just another tool. Similar dynamic to when consumers used to argue about the Zestimate — same argument, higher stakes.

Be helpful. Be professional. Show them how to prompt it correctly. And keep the focus on the client's outcome, not on defending your expertise from the machine.

Your next competitor isn't another realtor down the street. It's the AI sitting next to every client you're going to talk to for the rest of your career.

You have two choices. Fight it — get eaten within 12-24 months. Or learn to work alongside it, master professional-grade prompting, prompt every difficult scenario before your client does, keep polished conversations in your back pocket for every AI objection, and then reinvest all the time AI frees up into being more human than any competitor in your market.

AI wins the information war. You win the connection war. That's the entire game for the next decade.

Get in front of people. Sit at the kitchen table. Turn the camera on. Ask "you guys got real quiet — what's bothering you?" Read the body language. Notice the hesitation. Remember the details.

Do that consistently for the next 12 months. Nothing AI produces can compete with a genuine, present, professional human paying real attention.

Be more peopley. Get to work.

Ready to stop guessing and start producing?

🎯 Start Premier Coaching (free trial): premiercoaching.com
📲 Elite Coaching — text Tim directly: 512-758-0206

If you prompted AI professionally before every listing appointment and every offer presentation for the next 90 days — with the full transaction context Julie would ask about — and then invested the freed time in more in-person, camera-on conversations with your sphere, how much stronger would your book of business be a year from now?

— Tim & Julie Harris

📬 Thanks for reading Harris Real Estate Daily. Share this with a colleague who needs clarity about where the industry is headed.

Forwarded by a friend? Sign up with just one click here.

Share this issue.

FOR REAL ESTATE PROFESSIONALS READY TO LEVEL UP

You already know you can do more. Now you'll know exactly what to do.

Start Premier Coaching for $1 for your first seven days.