🎯 The 5-Rule Framework for Handling Lowball Offers

GROW WITH LIBERTAS & EXP REALTY

🎧 Listen on Apple Podcasts and Spotify!

A buyer offers $40,000 below asking price. The seller is offended. The listing agent calls it a lowball. The buyer's agent says it's justified. Before long, everyone is arguing over a number instead of asking a much better question — what is the market trying to tell us?

Today isn't about defending low offers. It's about understanding them, responding professionally, and using them to actually get homes sold.

Five rules that turn lowball drama into professional negotiation — plus the language you use with sellers before any offer arrives so they don't lose their marbles in your voicemail when a below-asking offer finally comes in.

The word lowball gets thrown around far too easily. An offer isn't a lowball simply because it's below asking price. The home might just be overpriced. If the buyer can support their offer with comparable sales, active competition, and current market conditions — that's not a lowball. That's negotiation.

A true lowball is an offer with little or no relationship to actual market value. As professionals, we should separate emotion from evidence before dismissing any offer.

Here's the specific move that eliminates 90% of lowball drama on the listing side. Immediately after signing the listing agreement — before the first showing — deliver this framing to your seller:

That single conversation is the difference between a seller who freaks out at the first below-asking offer and one who calmly says "okay, let's counter." You've pre-normalized the reality that some offers won't hit the number they were hoping for. You've given yourself permission to work aggressive offers instead of getting fired for presenting them.

Julie's analogy for this — turbulence on a plane. Pilots used to just fly through it. Now they announce it: "We're going to hit some turbulence, please buckle in." Same principle. Foreshadow the possibility of below-asking offers so nobody loses their marbles when one arrives.

Now the buyer side. Some buyers will insist on making below-market offers no matter what the comps say, what the market says, what you say, what AI says, or what their know-it-all uncle says. They're just going to lowball. It's how they buy things.

For 98% of these buyers, two questions dissolve the reflex:

Shut up. Let them answer.

The honest answer is almost always no. You've just gotten the buyer to concede that their offer wouldn't work if the roles were reversed.

The remaining 1-2% of buyers will still insist on making the aggressive offer. In that case — make the offer, but do the advanced move first.

Before you submit an aggressive offer, call the listing agent and prime them. Not to negotiate against your buyer — to prepare the listing agent to prepare the seller.

Cold aggressive offers sent to a listing agent with no warning produce angry sellers, hostile listing agents, and dead deals. Primed aggressive offers become starting points for actual negotiations. The difference is one 90-second phone call.

Exception to everything above: if it's a truly motivated seller, a rehab situation, or an obvious distressed listing — the rules change. Aggressive offers make sense. Have at it.

Too many listing agents prepare an excellent CMA, win the listing, and never revisit pricing again. That's a mistake — and it's a fiduciary failure.

The market changes every week, sometimes every hour. New listings hit. Homes go pending. Prices reduce. Builders introduce new incentives. Some builders even reduce prices on new construction, which pulls buyer traffic away from resales overnight.

Every active listing deserves a fresh CMA every 2-4 weeks. Not because you're looking for reasons to reduce the price — but because your fiduciary responsibility to your seller is ongoing until closing.

The question to ask yourself every 2-4 weeks: If we listed this property today as a fresh listing, where would we price it? Sometimes the answer won't change. Sometimes prices have gone up. Sometimes they need to come down. But you have to actually do the analysis to know.

Related move. Sometimes the CMA isn't the problem — the staleness is. Your listing is no longer new. It doesn't hit the new listing feed to buyer agents. Buyers scrolling portals skip it. It becomes old milk.

Hit hard reset every 30 days. New photos. New description. New price if warranted. Give it a fresh push into the market.

Advanced tactic that Tim and Julie used when carrying 30-40 active listings simultaneously — Tim had a license, Julie had a license, and they would flip listings back and forth between their licenses when needed to reset the days-on-market count. Were they working the MLS rules? Yes. Were they benefiting the seller they were legally obligated to represent? Absolutely. Know your local MLS rules — but understand the broader principle: staleness kills listings, and your fiduciary duty is to keep the property positioned to sell.

Here's the reframe most sellers need to hear. The buyer who made the below-asking offer is often the only buyer trying to purchase the home.

Meanwhile — 10 other buyers scheduled showings, made the seller clean the house and leave for an hour, and then either never showed up or disappeared without feedback. Those are the buyers to be mad at. They wasted the seller's time and produced nothing.

The buyer who submitted a real offer, at any price, gave you something valuable — a starting point. They committed. They showed intent. They wrote a number down on paper.

Which leads to the industry script: your first offer is often your best offer. Sometimes it's your only offer. Treat it accordingly.

Every listing that goes on to expire started with an early offer that the seller rejected as not good enough. Weeks later, no better offer came. Days-on-market ticked up. Buyers started assuming something was wrong with the property. Eventually the listing died. Don't fall victim to your own expired problem.

Frame it for your seller: "Mr. Seller, we've had 11 showings. This is the first offer. The 10 people who inconvenienced you and didn't make an offer are the ones we should be frustrated with — not this buyer, who's trying to actually buy your home. Let's treat this as our starting point and negotiate."

We don't know what's going on in the buyer's life or culture. Some people are trained by family, culture, or business background to never pay retail. It's normal. Don't take it personally. Respect the person who wrote a real offer.

Switching to the buyer side. A professional buyer's agent doesn't invent a number because the buyer wants a bargain. They study:

Then they explain the market to their buyer and craft an offer that the seller should at least be willing to counter. The goal isn't to steal the house (unless there's a genuine reason to, which there usually isn't). The goal is to buy it.

An informed offer starts a productive negotiation. An emotional offer starts an argument.

Here's a technique great buyer agents use when they legitimately believe a listing is overpriced. If you're coming in below list price, submit your own comps with the offer.

Why? Because there's a real chance the listing agent isn't experienced enough — or doesn't have the personal firepower — to tell the seller the truth. Maybe the listing agent's relationship with the seller has gotten sketchy. Maybe the seller is the listing agent's mother, brother, or best friend, and they're avoiding conflict. Maybe the listing agent just has a weaker personality than the seller. This happens constantly.

When you submit your own CMA supporting your buyer's offer, you're doing two things:

Sellers accept realities from neutral market data that they reject from their own agent. The buyer-agent-submitted CMA becomes the tool the listing agent uses to have the price conversation they've been avoiding.

Related trap. Some inexperienced buyer agents try to win exclusive representation by promising the buyer they'll get houses at 20%, 30%, or 40% off list. The buyers love hearing it. They sign the exclusive agreement immediately.

Then they walk into a house they love that's clearly priced right. They turn to the buyer agent and say "okay, let's see the 20% off you promised me." The buyer agent tries. The listing agent laughs. The seller doesn't budge. The offer fails. The buyer fires the agent for not delivering on the promise.

Never promise what the market can't deliver. Never let a buyer walk into an exclusive agreement expecting outcomes you can't produce. Your credibility is worth more than any single exclusive.

This may be the biggest takeaway of the entire episode. If the price doesn't work, look at the rest of the contract.

Every contract has multiple variables that create value. Price is only one of them:

Great negotiators understand that price is only one of the many terms that create value. Your job isn't to win every single point — it's to help both parties accomplish their goals.

Here's the underlying dynamic most agents miss. Over 90% of the time, price is not actually the most important thing to a seller. What they really care about is convenience.

People will sell their houses for significantly less than retail value to minimize hassle. Need proof? Look at every we-buy-houses wholesaler and iBuyer platform. They're buying houses at 20-30% discounts to market value — not because those houses are all junk, but because a huge segment of sellers value convenience over maximum price.

Which means if you can solve the seller's convenience concerns as part of the offer, you can often close the price gap without moving the price at all. The offer that includes a 60-day free rent-back for a seller who hasn't found their next home may be more valuable than a $30,000 higher offer without the accommodation.

Ask the listing agent what the seller cares about. Then structure the offer around it. You'd be shocked how often the answer isn't price.

Tim and Julie's record was a house in Mirfield they were selling with both sides of the transaction — buyer and seller both represented by them. Fourteen or 15 back-and-forths on nitpicky items. Every one of them stressful. Every one of them a moment where either side could have walked away.

But every back-and-forth kept the deal alive. And in the end, the house closed.

That's the mindset. Every deal has a version that works. Your job is to find it. Keep talking. Keep looking for common ground. Ask more questions. Trial-balloon different combinations before you put anything in writing. Don't let a deal die in your court.

Also worth mentioning — Tim's most memorable moment from that transaction was walking into the walkthrough to find the buyer already inside swinging a hammer, starting renovations because they'd guessed the lockbox code. There was no script for that. Just another entry in the proof-we-actually-sold-real-estate file.

While we're on entertaining lessons — the other classic. A closing at Albany Country Club. Seller had removed all the wall-to-wall carpeting before the walkthrough. Left the tack strips and nails all over the floor. Buyer walks in for the walkthrough, sees the disaster, calls the listing agent. Listing agent calls the seller.

Seller: "Well, it wasn't in the contract."
Listing agent: "It was nailed to the floor."

Lesson: the contract has to explicitly reference what stays. Fixtures. Fixtures nailed down. Personal property. Everything. Assumptions kill closings.

One more piece of advice worth pulling out separately. Before you put anything in writing — on either side — call the other agent and trial-balloon the terms verbally. No commitment. No paper. Just conversation.

You'll get real feedback without triggering the emotional escalation that formal offers can cause. You can adjust the structure before you commit anything to paper. You can find creative combinations of terms that neither side had considered. And you build a working relationship with the other agent that will help you close this deal and the next 20 deals with them.

Communication is the single biggest predictor of whether a deal closes or falls apart in the current market. The agents who pick up the phone dominate the ones who fire off contracts and hope for the best.

Not every below-asking offer is a lowball. Not every buyer who submits one is your enemy. Not every seller who receives one should feel insulted. The professional job is to separate emotion from evidence and use every offer as a starting point.

Prep your sellers before offers arrive. Update your CMAs every 2-4 weeks. Prime the listing agent before you send aggressive offers. Submit supporting comps when you're coming in below list. Look at every term in the contract when price alone doesn't work. Trial-balloon verbally before you write anything down. Ask what the seller actually cares about (usually not price).

And above all — never let a deal die in your court.

That's the mindset that separates the agents closing deals right now from the ones watching their pipelines evaporate.

Get to work.

Ready to stop guessing and start producing?

💼 Build wealth with Tim's eXp team: whylibertas.com/harris
📲 Elite Coaching — text Tim directly: 512-758-0206

If you ran the full 5-rule framework — pre-normalize below-asking with your sellers, update every CMA every 2-4 weeks, prime the listing agent on aggressive offers, submit supporting comps on the buyer side, and never let a deal die in your court — how many more transactions would you close over the next 12 months?

— Tim & Julie Harris

📬 Thanks for reading Harris Real Estate Daily. Share this with a colleague who needs clarity about where the industry is headed.

Forwarded by a friend? Sign up with just one click here.

Share this issue.