🚫 Stop Buying Real Estate Leads — the 5-Step Recovery Plan for 2026

UPGRADE WITH LIBERTAS & EXP REALTY

🎧 Listen on Apple Podcasts and Spotify!

At some point, buying leads stops feeling like a marketing strategy and starts feeling like a dependency. You tell yourself you can stop anytime. You swear this is the last month.

Then the portal rep calls with a special opportunity, and suddenly you're spending another $3,000 for the privilege of chasing someone who clicked on 12 houses, entered a fake phone number, and now claims they were just looking. Today, we're staging an intervention.

Not because buying leads is always bad — it isn't. But when your entire business depends on somebody else selling you access to consumers, you don't really own a business. You're renting one. And the landlord can raise the rent, cancel your lease, or change the terms of the agreement without asking you first.

Here's the five-step recovery plan — plus the RESPA lawsuit brewing quietly in the background that nobody at your brokerage is warning you about.

Before the steps — one grounding principle. You cannot build your castle, your future, or the lifeblood of your business on land you do not own.

Recent case in point: our sister podcast Powerhouse Talk had its Instagram account rug-pulled by Meta for no particular reason. Their AI flagged and cancelled millions of accounts, ours included. When our team pushed back, the response was some version of sorry, you violated terms of service, no specifics, no appeal path — either start a new account or spend six weeks fighting bureaucracy. Our team started a new account. No big deal for us, because the account wasn't load-bearing.

But if it had been load-bearing — if the entire lead flow for a business depended on that Instagram — the rug-pull would have ended the business.

The same dynamic applies to portal leads at 10x the intensity. If you're getting the lifeblood of your business from paid sources, the rules will change and you will lose 100% of the time without exception. You are, in essence, an extended employee of whoever the leading platform is. And employees don't get to negotiate their commission structure. The platform does.

One critical piece of context most agents don't have yet. Housing Wire and other industry publications have been covering multiple ongoing lawsuits alleging that the sale of consumer leads by Zillow (and other major portals) to real estate agents may violate RESPA — the Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act.

We're not going to litigate the legal question here. And we're not going to speculate on outcomes. But if your primary source of business has been buying leads from major portals, there is a non-zero chance that some or all of those lead-purchase arrangements will look dramatically different — or become unavailable — within the next 12 months.

The mainstream brokerage community isn't talking about this because too many of their agents are structurally dependent on the portals. The brokerages have a vested interest in you not thinking about it. Which is exactly why you should be thinking about it — right now — while there's still time to build alternative lead-generation muscle.

The first step is honest self-assessment. Are you buying leads because they're profitable and predictable, or because you don't know what else to do?

Judge your lead sources by the metrics that actually matter:

If you can't clearly explain what you spent, what you received, and what you earned from your lead-buying, you may not have a lead-generation system — you might just have an expensive hobby.

Here's the industry pattern that reveals the depth of the problem. Back when agents talked about production, they talked about dollars. I made $250K last year. I made $500K last year. Once portal leads became widespread, agents stopped talking about dollars and started talking about units and volume. I sold 100 houses. I closed $80M in volume.

Why the shift? Because when you actually run a profit-and-loss on a high-volume lead-buying business, the numbers are often shockingly small. The industry rewards transactions and total volume with awards, recognition, and social status. It does not reward net income. Which is why the real awards in real estate should go to the agents with the highest actual take-home — but nobody will ever run those awards, because the numbers would embarrass a lot of the industry's biggest names.

You know the dependency has taken over when you're afraid to turn it off.

The leads have become terrible. The conversion rate is microscopic. The referral fees are increasingly punitive. And you keep paying — because you're terrified that if you stopped, your phone would stop ringing entirely.

The fear is the trap.

The portal, the brokerage, the referral company, the lead vendor — every one of them controls the price, the territory, the rules, and even the consumer relationship. You're doing all the follow-up. You're doing all the showings. You're doing all the negotiations. You're carrying all the risk. And they're keeping a big piece of your commission — sometimes an enormous piece.

Public reporting on Zillow Flex arrangements suggests referral fees in the 40% range in some markets, with anecdotes of 43%. Some agents are allegedly paying flat monthly fees of $10,000+ on top of the referral share. And several coaching clients have reported pressure to send mortgage business to the portal's own lending arm — with the implicit understanding that lead quality or lead volume improves when they comply.

Is any of that leverage? Or is it the definition of dependence?

One important distinction. Traditional agent-to-agent referrals are completely different. If another agent refers you a client because they respect your work and can't service the deal, that's a healthy relationship. Standard is 25%. Anything meaningfully higher than that starts feeling less like a referral and more like something else. Peer-to-peer referrals are the good version. Portal dependency is the bad version. Don't confuse them.

Now that you've admitted the problem, this is where the real work starts. Stop waiting for strangers on the internet to raise their hand and start creating conversations yourself.

Concrete places to start:

None of this is as exciting as watching a new lead pop up in your CRM. But these activities create something dramatically more valuable — a business that belongs to you. You generated it. You control the message. You control the follow-up. You control the relationship. And critically — no referral fee for you.

Here's the description of peak real estate that most agents never experience because they never build their way to it.

You identify a target neighborhood. Maybe you pull an expired list. Maybe an FSBO. You call. You use the 7-step listing process we teach in Premier Coaching — convert, pre-qualify, set the appointment, send the pre-listing pack, present, close. The seller signs a listing contract with you. No portal fee. No referral split. No third party in the middle.

That sense of freedom and independence is irreplaceable. It's literally money — because 100% of your commission comes home instead of 60% or less.

And here's the surprise most agents never realize until they've built the muscle. When you know how to self-generate leads, you can live anywhere. You could be in Columbus, Ohio right now — like Tim and Julie were — and decide to move to Southern Florida. Get your license there (60-80 hours). Land in Florida and immediately start working expireds. Build an inventory within 90 days.

Getting your license in a new market is easier and less expensive than paying 40% referral fees on portal leads in your current market. That's the depth of the freedom that self-generation produces.

While you were chasing internet leads, there's a good chance you neglected the people who were most likely to actually hire you anyway.

Your recovery plan starts with reconnecting. Not with when are you planning to move? real estate breath. Just check in. Offer a home value update. Use the Ford script. Be a human first.

Here's the specific commitment we ask our coaching clients to make. Speak with 100% of the people in your database over the next 30, 60, or 90 days — whichever fits your list size.

If you have 200 people, that's less than four conversations per day for 60 days. That's fully achievable if you actually decide to do it. Most agents don't. Which is why most agents' databases are dormant assets producing almost nothing.

Real coaching example from about 45 days ago. Andy and Trent — Northern California, top eXp agents by volume — got an assignment. Each of them, five contacts per day. Any decision-making adult about buying or selling real estate. It didn't have to be a phone call. It could be the person in front of them at the grocery store. Someone in line at Starbucks. Someone at their gym.

Just five conversations per day, each, about real estate.

We did the calendar math. Subtracting weekends, holidays, and planned vacation days, ten total contacts per day between them for the rest of the year came out to roughly 2,200 contacts by year-end.

They committed. Two weeks later, they showed up to a coaching call laughing. "Tim, we don't want to admit to you how well it worked, because we know you're just going to make us do more of it."

That's the pattern. Five years into a real estate career with consistent database work, 80% of your business will come from centers of influence and past clients. Provided you actually talk to them. They will not do it on their own.

If you want to make money right now, work expireds and FSBOs — hands already in the air. If you want to build a business that produces income for decades without buying anything, work the database.

Do both. But do them in balance — not by outsourcing both to a portal.

Here's the goal — not necessarily to eliminate paid leads entirely, but to put them in their proper place. Supplement, not core.

Agent-to-agent referrals are fine. Occasional relocation referrals are fine. What we're specifically staging the intervention around is the monthly hamster wheel — the recurring subscription to a paid lead source that becomes the entire business.

Your long-term plan should include:

Every month, a larger percentage of your business should come from assets you control. When you look at your pending transactions, you should see fewer and fewer with a referral fee attached to them.

The real measure of success isn't how many leads you can afford to buy. It's how much business you can create without asking permission, without paying rent, and without giving away a third of your commission.

The clearest reframe of the entire episode:

Buying a lead gives you a name. Building a business gives you a future.

They are not the same thing. A lead is a one-time speculation. A business is a compounding asset. Most agents have never really internalized the difference — which is why they can spend $50,000+ per year on lead purchases and end the year with no more real business than they had when they started.

Practical exit framework if you're currently dependent:

Don't quit cold turkey if paid leads are your only source of business. That will kill your income before your replacement pipeline is built. Some of our elite clients did quit cold turkey — because they had built the alternatives first, or because they were financially secure enough to weather the transition.

Do start building the alternatives immediately. Every dollar spent on paid leads should have an equivalent dollar of time investment going into proactive lead generation this quarter. Database calls. Expireds. FSBOs. Open houses. Community embedding. Every conversation is a deposit into the account that will eventually replace the portal spend entirely.

Track the shift. Every month, calculate the percentage of your pending transactions with a referral fee attached versus without. When the referral-fee percentage starts dropping, you're winning. When it's below 20% of your business, you're free.

Never advise a new agent to buy leads. That's the worst advice possible for someone entering the industry. It teaches them to be dependent from day one. It skips the skill development that would make them independent for the rest of their careers. It ensures they'll fail the first time the platform changes terms.

Never buy leads as an entry strategy. The whole point of getting into real estate is to build something that produces freedom. If you're going to be an independent contractor, be independent. Otherwise you've just moved from being employed by a company to being employed by a lead generation platform — with none of the benefits of actual employment.

Buying leads is not a business model. It's a rental agreement with a landlord who can change the terms whenever it suits them. And the RESPA lawsuits currently in motion suggest the terms may change dramatically over the next 12 months — with or without your input.

You still have time to break the dependency and build something you actually own. The five steps aren't complicated. Admit the problem. Recognize its power. Take responsibility. Reconnect with the people you've neglected. Build the assets that produce leads without buying them.

Nine to twelve months of consistent execution changes the entire structure of your business. You stop dreading the monthly portal invoice. You stop crossing your fingers on the next lead quality shift. You stop giving away 40% of your commission to someone whose only contribution was sending you a phone number.

You start owning the mansion instead of renting it.

Stop buying leads. Get to work.

Ready to stop guessing and start producing?
💼 Build wealth with Tim's eXp team: whylibertas.com/harris
📲 Elite Coaching — text Tim directly: 512-758-0206

If you replaced every dollar of paid-lead spend with equivalent hours of proactive prospecting for the next 90 days — how much of your current portal dependency do you think would still exist by year-end?

— Tim & Julie Harris

📬 Thanks for reading Harris Real Estate Daily. Share this with a colleague who needs clarity about where the industry is headed.

Forwarded by a friend? Sign up with just one click here.

Share this issue.

Most books about Puerto Rico focus on tax strategies or travel tips. The Dorado Beach Insider goes deeper.

Written by Tim and Julie Harris, this practical guide combines firsthand experience with expert insight into Act 60, real estate, relocation, schools, healthcare, hurricanes, and the everyday realities of life on Puerto Rico's Gold Coast.

Whether you're considering a move, investing in real estate, or simply curious about island life, this is the guide you'll wish you had before making the leap.

👉 Order your copy on Amazon today.

GROW WITH LIBERTAS & EXP REALTY

Join a brokerage built around agent success.

Get access to industry-leading coaching, practical training, business systems, and a network of agents focused on growth.

Explore Libertas eXp Realty → whylibertas.com/harris or text Tim directly at 512-758-0206.