🤝 How to Ethically Take an Overpriced Listing in 2026

UPGRADE WITH LIBERTAS & EXP REALTY

🎧 We’re also on Apple Podcasts and Spotify!

Picture this. You ran the comps. The home is worth $520K. You sit down with the seller and they hit you with $600K. Most agents either argue and lose the listing, or cave and take an overpriced listing that won't sell. Both are wrong.

In thousands of transactions over thirty years, the number of sellers who thought their house was worth less than the CMA said it was worth is exactly zero. Every seller overprices. Every single one. It's not greed.

It's not stupidity. It's that the house is their stuff — and humans cannot see their own possessions objectively. Once you accept that as a fact, the entire pricing conversation changes.

Before any pricing script will work, you have to scrub certain words from your vocabulary completely. Specifically — personal pronouns.

The moment you say "my CMA," "my price," or "your price," you've turned the conversation adversarial. You're now on the opposite side of the table. The seller's ego registers it before their conscious mind does, and they start defending. They won't tell you that's what happened. They'll just list with someone else and tell you "we didn't really hit it off."

Replace those words with neutral language:

That shift, by itself, will win you listings you would have otherwise lost. It costs nothing, takes zero extra time, and almost no agent in your market is doing it.

The autopsy on most lost listings starts before the appointment. If you didn't pre-qualify the seller fully — motivation, time frame, what they think the house is worth, what they owe, whether you're competing with other agents — you're walking in blind, and you'll spend the appointment trying to do the pre-qualification work in the seller's living room. That's a losing position.

The pricing question specifically belongs on the phone before you go, not at the kitchen table. Here's the script that gets it out of them naturally:

"Mr. Seller, the CMA is going to take some real time, and part of the job is choosing the right comps. Help me with one thing first — offer me your advice. What properties have you seen in the neighborhood over the last 6-12 months that you thought were most similar to your house?"

Then shut up and listen.

People love to give advice. When you ask for theirs, they feel compelled to deliver. They'll name comps. "Bob and Susie's place at 123 Elm sold for $580." You say: "Oh, I remember that one. How was that one similar to yours?" — and pull up the listing on your screen to verify the number live.

Then: "What are the two others that come to mind?" Not "any others" (which gets a no). "The two others that come to mind." They'll give you two more.

By the end of three minutes, you have three comps and a price range. That's the seller's mental price for the house. Now you know what you're walking into — and you can build the pre-listing pack and your strategy around it instead of being surprised in their kitchen.

There's a specific tell. If a seller refuses to give you any comps — claims they haven't looked, doesn't know the neighborhood, can't think of anything — those are almost always the worst overpricers. They know their target number is unrealistic and they don't want to expose the gap. Combine that with no real motivation and no time frame, and you've identified a seller whose only goal is hitting a fantasy number. They'd be happy to never sell.

Those are sellers you might walk away from — not because they overpriced, but because they have no motivation at all. Big difference.

For everyone else with real motivation, the goal isn't to make them right. It's to take the listing in a way that gets you the price reduction later without a fight.

Here's the part that makes some agents uncomfortable, and they need to get over it.

The market says $520K. The seller thinks $600K. You've sent the CMA. You've sent the net sheet showing three price tiers and what each one nets them at close. You've told them clearly what the data says. Then you give them permission to price it where they want — with one specific condition built into the listing conversation:

"Mr. Seller, I appreciate the fact that you feel the house is worth $80,000 more than what the market is telling us. Let's agree to this. After two weeks or 10 showings — whichever happens first — if we don't have a written, verified offer on the property, we will revisit how the house is positioned on the market so that it correctly reflects the market's expectations."

Read that script again. Notice what isn't in it:

And notice what is in it:

Adjust the trigger to your local market. In a faster market, five days or five showings. In a luxury market where days on market are measured in months, 30 days or five showings. Whatever's realistic.

This is the part most agents miss entirely. If you skip this conversation when you take the listing, and the house doesn't sell at $600K — even though you delivered an honest CMA at $520K — the seller will forget your warning. Sixty days later they'll be angry. "Well, that was your price, right? You should have told me." And they'll fire you. The agent who took it overpriced and didn't condition the seller upfront loses the listing twice — once when it doesn't sell, and once when they get terminated.

The two-weeks-or-10-showings script protects you. It's pre-built into the listing agreement conversation. When the trigger hits and you call to reposition, you're not delivering bad news. You're executing a plan the seller already agreed to.

When the trigger hits and you call to discuss repositioning, don't suggest a number. Ask them:

"You're right — it's been two weeks, we've had nine showings, we talked through the feedback. What price did you have in mind?"

Roughly half the time they'll come back with a number lower than you would have suggested. They've been watching the showings, hearing the feedback, doing their own math. They've already moved mentally. You just have to let them say it first.

Your job in that moment is to protect them from cutting too deep — if they go below market, you talk them back up to the right number. But don't talk yourself into oblivion. Let them lead.

There's one more thing that will sink everything above if you ignore it. Sellers don't list with the agent who's most analytical. They list with the agent who believed in their house.

You can deliver the perfect pre-listing pack. The perfect CMA. The perfect net sheet. Run the perfect seven-step listing process. And still lose to a brand-new agent who walked in two weeks into their license with energy, enthusiasm, and genuine excitement about the property. We've seen this happen on a million-dollar listing in our own backyard — lost to a new agent who said "because we just didn't think you believed in our house."

When you go on a listing appointment, it is showtime. Not in a performative, fake way. In a genuinely-care-about-this-house way. Find something to love about the property. Mean it. Tell the seller. The pricing script will only land if the seller already likes you and believes you believe in their home.

The fastest way to lose a listing you should have won — start playing decorator, home inspector, or stager.

You are not there to point out that the wallpaper looks dated (the seller installed it 40 years ago with a beloved aunt who's now passed). You are not there to flag the carpet color. You are not there to inspect the hot water heater. You are not there to suggest removing the show ponies from the family room.

You don't know what eggshells you're walking on. Sellers are not objective about their homes. Keep your mouth shut on aesthetics and condition during the listing appointment. That feedback comes later, after the contract is signed, and ideally from a third party.

Here's the advanced move when the house actually does need work. Take the listing first. Then bring in a home stager. Hand the stager your list of issues privately. Let the stager deliver the bad news.

Sellers will receive "remove the wallpaper" from a disinterested third party as helpful, professional advice. They'd have received the same exact words from you as a personal insult. Same content. Different messenger. Totally different outcome. The contract's already signed by the time the stager walks in, so even if the seller bristles slightly, you don't lose the listing.

Two weeks have passed. 10 showings happened. No written, verified offer. You call:

They'll say yes. You've let them have the win at the start. You've referenced the data they've already seen. You've kept the language neutral. You've named the deadline they themselves set. And you've eliminated the ego fight before it started.

Don't lose listings over price. Don't argue with sellers about the value of their home. Don't ride a moral high horse about "I refuse to take overpriced listings" — meanwhile some other agent takes it, gets the price reduction six weeks later, and earns $30K you walked away from.

Pre-qualify before you go. Strip personal pronouns. Build the two-weeks-or-10-showings clause into every listing conversation. Show genuine energy and enthusiasm for the property. Don't critique anything in the home. Use a stager as the messenger for condition feedback. And when the trigger hits, run the repositioning script.

The secret of being a successful listing agent is having the listing when it sells. Take it. Position it. Sell it. Win.

Ready to stop guessing and start producing?

🎯 Start Premier Coaching (free trial): premiercoaching.com
📲 Elite Coaching — text Tim directly: 512-758-0206

Of your last five lost listings — how many do you think you lost on price versus how many you actually lost because of pronouns, energy, or unsolicited decorating advice?

— Tim & Julie Harris

📬 Thanks for reading Harris Real Estate Daily. Share this with a colleague who needs clarity about where the industry is headed.

Forwarded by a friend? Sign up with just one click here.

Share this issue.

GROW WITH LIBERTAS & EXP REALTY

Join a brokerage built around agent success.

Get access to industry-leading coaching, practical training, business systems, and a network of agents focused on growth.

Explore Libertas eXp Realty → whylibertas.com/harris or text Tim directly at 512-758-0206.